When buying a mapping or surveying drone, the selection is rapidly narrowed to a fixed-wing airplane mixed with Vertical Takeoff and Touchdown (VTOL) for its vastly larger vary, versatility and ease of use. Inside this phase, there are a number of commercial-grade options of European origin. However evaluating their capabilities and limitations may be tough.
The next comparability was made to supply an in depth perception into the traits of the main suppliers on this subject. The information has been verified throughout a number of sources. A number of points have been calculated to supply a constant illustration of the info. The calculation strategies and sources are offered on the backside of this text.
The platforms chosen for this comparability are:
The DeltaQuad Professional #MAP by Vertical TechnologiesThe WingtraOne by WingtraThe Trinity F90+ by Quantum SystemsThe Marlyn by AtmosUAVThe eBee X by SenseFly
Within the first part, you can find a fast overview of probably the most crucial points related to any mapping or surveying answer. After that, you can find a full listing evaluating each recognized and related specification. Lastly, the evaluation features a listing of sources and references so that you could be confirm the objectivity of this comparability.
A fast rundown of probably the most crucial points which are related to mapping.
DELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XMax. Flight Time110 minutes59 minutes90 minutes50 minutes60/90 minutesProtection
At 3CM/PX1200 hectares450 hectares800 hectares360 hectares220/500 hectaresMax Management Vary50 KM & Limitless10 KM7 KM20 KM8 KMMost Decision
Megapixel61 MP42 MP42 MP42 MP24 MPStay Video✓XXXXSwappable Payloads✓✓✓X✓Comparative
Bundle Worth€ 19.593€ 29.600€ 21.990€ 29.450€ 22.550
Max flight time is calculated at sea stage with digicam payload.The protection is calculated by multiplying the utmost flight distance by the utmost digicam decision. It’s primarily based on 3CM per pixel with an overlap of 50%.To check pricing a bundle was chosen for every mannequin that almost all carefully resembles: 42MP digicam, <1CM PPK, 2 Batteries, Customary radio, GCS (if obtainable).
Most surveying space in HectaresThe most space that may be mapped in a single flight is set by a number of components comparable to digicam decision, cruise pace, endurance, and lens choices.This comparability relies on the best decision provided for every platform, mixed with the utmost flight distance. The values have been calculated primarily based on 3cm per pixel decision and a 50% picture overlap. The values have then been compensated to account for the digicam’s minimal set off interval.
Most telemetry rangeThe most vary at which the UAV may be managed. Lengthy-range communications is necessary for corridor-type surveys comparable to energy traces, pipelines, railways, and roads.The indicated ranges are the utmost radio vary as specified by the provider. Nominal ranges may be decrease.
Most picture resolutionThe most picture decision in Megapixels is the whole variety of pixels that make up a single picture. This may be an necessary issue for a fixed-wing/VTOL UAV.A better decision permits:– Masking bigger areas– Flying at greater altitudes– Producing greater decision finish outcomes– Higher post-processing efficiency with extra accuracy
Most flight time
The utmost flight time for fixed-wing UAV is dependent upon the altitude above sea stage. Because the altitude will increase, the UAVs must fly quicker resulting from a decrease air density. Nonetheless, the decrease air density additionally supplies much less drag, due to this fact generally the utmost flight distance stays the identical in any respect altitudes.The indicated most flight instances are at sea stage whereas carrying a daily digicam payload.
On this part, all points of the chosen platforms are in contrast. Most points are primarily based on the printed specs by the producers. Some points had been derived or calculated. On the backside of this text you can find an evidence of the calculation strategies.
Platform SpecificationsDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XCountry Of OriginThe NetherlandsSwitzerlandGermanyThe NetherlandsSwitzerlandPlatform TypeRedundant VtolVtol TailsitterVtol TiltrotorVtol TailsitterFixed-wingCruise Velocity16m/S16m/S17m/S14m/S11m/SMax. Flight Time110 Minutes59 Minutes90 Minutes50 Minutes60/90 MinutesMax. Flight Distance
(Cruise * Time – 10%)100km50km90km40km55kmPayload Capability1200g800g700g800g800gRadio Vary20km/30km/50km
LTE (Limitless)10km7km7km/20km8kmLive Mapping Video✓XXXXZero Pre-flight Calibrations✓XXX✓4G/LTE Assist✓XXXXFPV Video Assist✓XXXXSwappable Payloads✓✓✓X✓Supported Cameras61MP Sony A7R-IV42MP Sony A7R-III42MP Sony RX1R-II24MP Sony A6000Micasense Rededge MxMicasense AltumFlir Duo Professional R20MP Sony QX142MP Sony RX1R IIMicasense Rededge-mxMicasense Altum20MP Sony UMC42MP Sony RX1R IIMicasense Rededge-mxMicasense Altum42MP Sony RX1RII42MP A7CMicasense Rededge-mxMicasense Altum24MP AREAX20MP SODAParrot SequoiaMicasense
Rededge MxMapping PerformanceDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XMaximum Picture Decision61 Megapixel42 Megapixel42 Megapixel42 Megapixel24 MegapixelCoverage At 3CM/PX1200 Ha450 Ha800 Ha360 Ha220ha/500 HaMaximum Hall Size50 Km5 Km7 Km20 Km8 KmLowest GSD0.four CM/PX0.7 CM/PX0.7 CM/PX0,85 CM/PX1.zero CM/PXRTK/PPK SetupDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XGPS BandL1 & L2L1 & L2L1L1 & L2L1Precision<1cm3cm3cmBase Station Accessible✓X✓X✓Software program FeaturesDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XSmart Mission Planning✓✓✓✓✓Good Mission Plan Validation✓XXXXFlight Simulator✓XXX✓Terrain Following✓✓✓X✓Automated Takeoff & Land✓✓X✓XSafety FeaturesDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XRedundant Flight System✓XXXXADS-B✓✓✓X✓Stay Nostril Digital camera (FPV)✓XXXXTolerancesDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XMaximum Wind45 Km/H40 Km/H43 Km/H45km/H35 Km/HMax. Takeoff & Touchdown Wind33 Km/H30 Km/H33 Km/H
(25km/H above 1500m)45km/H (Unverified)35km/HMax. Takeoff Altitude4000m2500m4000m4000m5000mTemperature Vary-20 To +45 C-10 To +40 C-12 To +50 C-10 To +40 C-15 To + 40cHandlingDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XSetup Time1 Minute5 Minutes7 Minutes5 Minutes10 MinutesControl TypeIntegrated Contact-screen Controller with Mission Planning, Stay video, and Guide Management JoysticksAnalog ControllerAnalog ControllerAnalog ControllerAnalog ControllerGround Management Station OptionsIntegrated ControllerTabletField LaptopCommand Middle IntegrationTabletNot Included
A Laptop computer Is Required To OperateNot Included
A Laptop computer Is Required To OperateNot Included
A Laptop computer Is Required To OperateAutonomyFull
MappingManual OverrideAssisted Guide Management In Fastened Wing And Hover FlightManual Management In Fastened Wing And Hover FlightManual Management In Hover Flight OnlyManual Management In Fastened Wing And Hover FlightManual Management In Fastened Wing OnlyTakeoff Weight6.2 Kg4.5 Kg5.0kg6.7kg1.6kgWing Span235 Cm125 Cm239cm160cm116cmTransport caseRugged FlightcaseBackpackSoft CaseSoft Case
Rugged optionalSoft CaseCosts ComparisonPricing for probably the most resembling packagesDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XPackage ContentsUAV2 Batteries1cm PPK42mp RX1RII20km Radio LinkTabletUAV2 Batteries1cm PPK42mp RX1RII10km Radio LinkTabletUAV2 Batteries3cm PPK42mp RX1RII7km Radio LinkUAV2 Batteries1cm PPK42mp RX1RII7km Radio LinkUAV2 Batteries3cm PPK24mp Areax8km Radio LinkComparative Bundle Worth€ 19.593,00€ 29.600,00€ 21.990,00€ 29.450,00€ 22.550,00Choices & PricingDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XPlatform Worth€ 9.999,00€ 15.755,89€ 15.900,00€ 16.950,00€ 14.00zero,00 (90KM)Battery€ 499,00€ 420,00€ 640,00unknown€ 400PPK 3cm€ 899,00not availableincludednot obtainable€ four.950PPK 1cm€ 1.299,00includednot obtainable+- € 7.500not availablePPK Base Station€ 2.600,00not availablenot availablenot obtainable€ 5.350Transmission System20KM+Pill: € 1.299
30KM + built-in controller: € three.499
50KM + built-in controller: € 5.49910KM+Pill: included7KM: included7KM: included
20KM: unknown7KM: includedLive Mapping and FPV VideoIncluded with built-in controller optionnot availablenot availablenot availablenot available4G/LTE Management and VideoIncluded with built-in controller optionnot availablenot availablenot availablenot obtainable61mp Sensor (Sony A7R4)€ 6.699,00not availablenot availablenot availablenot obtainable42mp Sensor (Sony RX1RII)€ 5.299,00€ 6.500,00€ 5.450,00+- € 7.000not obtainable20mp/24mp Sensor€ 1.299,00€ 2.100,00€ 2.290,00not obtainable€ three.600Micasense Rededge MXWith DLS & Calibration Panel€ 7.299,00€ 5.900
(with out DLS)€ 6.890,00+- € eight.00zero+- € eight.000Micasense Altum With DLS & Calibration Panel€ 12.999,00€ 12.100,00
(with out DLS)€ 12.750,00+- € 13.000not availableFlir Duo Professional R€ 7.900,00not availablenot availablenot availablenot availableLidar + Softwarenot availablenot obtainable€ 60.100,00not availablenot availableSOURCESDELTAQUAD PRO #MAPWINGTRAONETRINITY F90+MARLYNEBEE XPricingDeltaQuad configuratorWingtra ConfiguratorPrice listQuotation
Reseller ResellerSpecificationsDeltaQuad specificationsWingtra specificationsUser manualSpec listing GeoMatchingSenseFly specs
Most flight time
The utmost flight time relies on flying at sea stage. The DeltaQuad, Wingtraone and eBee X indicated their flight time relies on carrying the usual mapping payload. The Trinity F90+ and Marlyn didn’t specify this.
Most flight distance
The utmost flight distance is calculated by multiplying the cruise pace by the max flight time, and decreasing the worth by 10% to accomodate for takeoff and touchdown. The calculation was carried out this fashion as not all producers use the identical technique for specifying the utmost flight distance.
Most surveying Space
This comparability relies on the best decision provided for every platform, mixed with the utmost flight distance. The values have been calculated primarily based on 3cm per pixel decision and a 50% picture overlap. The values have then been compensated to account for the digicam’s minimal set off interval.
Meeting and pre-flight calibration time was both specified and/or decided by watching operation movies for various platforms.
The utmost wind was calculated primarily based on the provider specification. It was then restricted by cruise pace, and diminished with 5 meters per second to permit ample ahead flight for mapping.
This worth needs to be primarily based on sea stage as wind tolerance will increase at greater altitudes. It appears that evidently not all suppliers are itemizing these values at sea stage.
Comparative bundle worth
A worth was requested for all platforms primarily based on the Following specs:
– 42MP digicam
– 1CM PPK (if obtainable)
– 2 Batteries
– Customary radio answer
– Floor Management Station (if obtainable)
The Trinity F90+ and eBee X don’t present <1CM PPK
The Trinity F90+, Marlyn and eBee X don’t present a Floor Management Station
The Trinity F90+ comes with a 3CM PPK base station included
The information on this comparability has been fastidiously verified throughout a number of sources, however inaccuracies can happen. Please confirm all points with the platform suppliers. This text is for data functions solely, no rights may be derived from this information.
Please give a like or touch upon Fb for assist Us
Go to our store Greatest Drone Store
Go to our sponsor Virtualrealityuse